since 1940

Home> Maintaining your Continental  and Lycoming engine

Fatigue fractured cylinder base stud from insufficient preload. Notice black fretting material around stud.

A. The only reason I can think of for re-torquing the joint would be a as quality control measure to make sure all nuts were properly torqued to begin with. If assembled properly, cylinder base nuts will not be loose after the run-in period.  If you find the nuts loose you have an engine failure. To quote from Lycoming Service Instruction 1097 "On most Lycoming direct drive models it is necessary to check clearance at crankshaft at the main bearing journal at any time cylinder base nuts are re-torqued. See SB272 for details of this problem."

In determining the proper torque value for a given stud:

•  the elastic limit and operating pressures are taken into consideration so that the resulting torque value approaches the elastic limit of the material of the stud
• and the preload produced by the proper torque is greater than the operating load.

If properly torqued, a stud cannot fail in fatigue since it does not experience cyclic stress. If a stud is loose, it experiences cyclic stress and is subject to fatigue failure.

 A loose stud places the adjacent studs  under a greater operating pressure and likely to be stressed beyond their elastic limit. Therefore, all of the hold-down studs must be replaced.

On my airplane no mechanic is going to install cylinders until he shows me the calibration sticker on his torque wrench and shows me that he has a copy of the Lycoming or Continental engine procedure on installing cylinders and torquing.

BAD - thick paint under hold-down nut If joints are soft they work loose. As the material under the nut extrudes out the joint loosens resulting in cyclic stress loads to the stud and stud fatigue failure.	GOOD - no or very thin layer of paint under nut Lycoming's overhaul manual specifies a maximum paint film thickness under the cylinder hold-down nut.

Torque Wrench Extension Calculator Download our free Torque Wrench Extension Calculator - file size: 1.46MB this small windows program computes what wrench setting to use when using an extension to your torque wrench

GOOD - Lycoming cylinder showing thin zinc chromate paint layer

Cylinder base studs are found  loose for the following reasons:

•  Insufficient preload to resist applied forces caused from insufficient initial tightening (low torque or high friction.
• Overtorqued originally beyond the yield point
• Joint thickness has reduced due to  fretting or wearing away of material between the joints or, extruding of material from between joints 
• Improper design either from low specified torque or unknown service forces.

beware though - the break-a-way torque is a poor indicator of the prevailing torque

Copyright 2003 by Sacramento Sky Ranch Inc. All rights reserved.  Prices subject to change without notice. Not responsible for typographical or misprint.
Disclaimer: sacskyranch.com contains abundant information relating to aircraft maintenance. The information provided  is not intended to supercede or supplement the F.A.A. approved  maintenance and/or operator’s manuals. Those F.A.A. approved manuals must be utilized when performing maintenance and/or operating aircraft.